
Although I love Taraji and Madea I just can’t get down with Tyler Perry’s style of filmmaking. As a current film student it makes me cringe when I see how successful Tyler Perry is but how inexplicably sloppy his filmmaking is done. I keep trying to figure out whether it’s beause I am a snob or whether I don’t like his style or if he is just not talented and none of those are 100% true. The best reasoning behind my sour feelings for him as a director is summed up in this statement by Stefan Sharff:
When a proper cinema “syntax” is used, the viewer is engaged in an active process of constantly “matching” chains of shots not merely by association or logical relationship but by an empathy peculiar to cinema. The blend so achieved spells cinema sense–a mixture of emotion and understanding, meditative or subliminal, engaging the viewers ability to respond to a structured cinema “language”…A cinematic syntax yields meaning not only through the surface content of shots but also through their connections and mutual relationships.
Some may call me a HATER or a total hypocrite as I do support Tyler Perry’s films in the hopes that he has learned one more thing about filmmaking that will better him during his reign as king of “black” cinema with each new film that he does. But he keeps disappointing me and I keep going back! Am I a whore for Madea? What gives!?!?!
My gripe is that he abominates everything in the aforementioned statement and he creates films for dare I say a dumb ass audience. He doesn’t challenge his viewers AT ALL! Instead he creates 2 hour bad dreams in which they can relive and affirm the emotional trenches of all the things gone wrong or things salvaged through JESUS in their lives.
This formula is extremely problematic for me as I know that his audience is predominantly black and he is in some sense a cinematic voice of “GOD” for these poor souls.
Film is supposed to challenge your way of viewing, not create CEREBRAL INERTIA! Enough Hateration… I am sure I will be back to gripe on this subject. What do you think?








